Jay A. has been a public-school teacher for almost two decades, and he sends his three sons to St. Peter Lutheran in Appleton. This is no paradox—many Wisconsin families have ties to both public and private schools and find success in exercising their right to have educational options. When deciding where to send his own children, Jay didn’t have to search far to find St. Peter. The school is well known in the community for their early childhood care, and his family lives close to the campus. He says they took a leap of faith when enrolling the two oldest…